Horsegirl – Phonetics On and On
Producer Cate Le Bon helps the trio move away from the more obvious pastiche of their debut, but it’s not without its problems.
On their second LP, Horsegirl craves a minimalistic vision that reveals an unassuming side to their music. Striking in their immediacy, the Chicago trio aims for playfulness and openness exhibited in their fairly sparse guitar pop. Sometimes, like in the strings-laden “2468,” they lock into a jaunty groove that, while lacking in lyrical acumen, brims with infectious energy. Often rooted in spontaneity rather than overthinking things too much, both “Switch Over” and “Rock City” resort to endearingly shambling instrumentals and whimsical vocal harmonies that come off with good-natured charm.
Musically, their low-stakes arrangements fail to ignite much of a spark. But occasionally, like in “Where’d You Go?,” they pair loose freakout solos with jittery, The Feelies-like rhythms quite capably. Indie rock whisperer Cate Le Bon does help the trio move away from the more obvious pastiche of their debut, Versions of Modern Performance. But in refining their approach, Horsegirl stumbles onto a new set of influences that takes away from their true identity. Nevertheless, there are flashes of brilliance—“Frontrunner,” accented with a lovely twang, details a story of romantic yearning that hits deeper as it progresses. These more relatable moments would’ve elevated an album that, to its credit, has the sounds of the past they emulate down pat.
Phonetics On and On was released on 14 February 2025 via Matador.
No Ripcord reviews will always be free to read. If you value independent music criticism, you can support the site with a $20 annual subscription.
Comments ()