Music Reviews
Merriweather Post Pavilion

Animal Collective Merriweather Post Pavilion

(Domino) Buy it from Insound Rating - 10/10

“(M)uch of this is pure hype… a social version of the TV quiz show where contestants are asked to guess not the true answer to a question, but the answer that polls have shown most people believe is true…” from “The Last President of the United States,” an essay by Greil Marcus, first published in Artforum in 1985

The currency of hype, the elephant in the bedroom of contemporary music writing, is difficult to schematize, but I would say that it roughly equates to word-of-mouth, plus the apparatuses of journalism, plus a special x-factor. Most bands associated with the h-word have x-factors that involve an aggregate of various extra-musical marginalia, like shticks, fashions, geographies, back-stories, unifying visual aesthetics… the stuff that we writers use to fatten our paragraphs and self-aggrandize our profession without having to go through the trouble of listening to anything too closely.  Unless you count cryptic internet press-releases, fake names, and optical illusions (I might not blame you), Animal Collective dropped most of their serious shtick when they stopped wearing masks. Their x-factor is a rare one: they make fantastic, unique, relentlessly singular records with a regularity that suggests an enchanted acumen. You probably don’t need me to tell you that Merriweather Post Pavilion is yet another of these. So why are we so excited? When are we going to start taking this band for granted?

“(if you're into Fleet Foxes this is like an electronic version from Brooklyn)” – from an Amazon user review of MPP credited to Sister Moon

Like the nuances of hype, the consensus that creates “universal acclaim” is impossible to telegraph, yet the sacrosanct merits of universality pervade the way that we talk about music. Ergo, Fleet Foxes: the grounds for this record’s copious year end accolades seem more firmly rooted in its alleged universal appeal than in the quality of its music. Certainly the nature of the music is factored in, with the album being touted as a time capsule from a great American past that no one has ever experienced but have somehow remembered upon hearing. The underlying assumption is clear: the essence of Fleet Foxes resides in Plato's realm of the forms; we all know it when we hear it, even if we can't put our finger on it. A question, if I may beg: what came first, the acclaim or the (instant) classic?

I'm being a tad bit facetious, of course. Perhaps I'm comfortable with overstating the raves of Fleet Foxes because I am in the minority of people who find the record incredibly underwhelming. I would love nothing more than to earnestly occupy this same dissenting minority with regard to Merriweather Post Pavilion; my review angle would be crystal clear and I evidently love the contrarian shtick. MPP will surely hold steady as one of 2009's touchstones, one whose exclusion from lists of year-end-bests would represent a more profound gesture than its inclusion. Yet here I am, haplessly enveloped into the nebulous realm of "universal acclaim," kicking my pebble of praise at the foot of the imminent mountain...

"We don't have a word for it… It's our own form of soul music.” - Panda Bear, speaking on Animal Collective’s musical style, from an interview with the Jerusalem Post in October of 2008

The first song on Merriweather Post Pavilion is called In the Flowers and it begins with a vision in passing: Avey Tare is on his way home when he spies a boy, stoned and care free, dancing in a field. Where this scene might normally typify the AC aesthetic, all bucolic wonder and unfettered elation, here Tare appears as if confronted with an alien spectacle: he’s got something on his mind (his wife, his absence from her life, his longing for her embrace) that renders him unable to crib off the dancer’s joy. Tare simply cannot reconcile his own sadness with a space where another human can be so happy; anyone who has experienced any degree of depression would surely understand this, and marvel accordingly at the turn that follows.

A classic escapist incantation (“If I could just leave my body for the night”) announces a rapturous sound blast, the plaintive haze of the song’s opening minutes exploding with drums and synthesizers.  Tare consoles himself in tune, seeing the dance anew: “Then we could be dancing no more missing you while I am gone / Then we could be dancing and you’d smile and say I like this song / And then ours would meet them we will recognize nothing’s wrong." (Before I took the effort to look up the lyrics I had misplaced that first line, hearing it as “Then he could be dancing over missing you all along,” a line that I prefer to the one provided and have come to consider as an incidental nuance to the actual lyrics. At points the singing style, the full mouthed annunciation, seems to invite this kind of alternate hearing, this accidental multi-valence).  

On In the Flowers, Avey Tare chooses creativity and empathy over bitterness and jealousy, refracts his sadness into tribute, takes the lemons he's been sitting on, squeezes them dry, quenches his thirst, and blows his own mind.  Domesticity and romance have never sounded as ecstatic and radical as they do on Merriweather Post Pavilion.  I never imagined myself as the kind of person who would swoon over a song about wanting nothing more than a house for the wife and kids, but boy do I swoon over My Girls. Such is AC's knack for de-familiarization, for projecting the seemingly banal through the prism of aural love. For as long as their lyrics have been (relatively) audible Animal Collective have written about peering at the little things in life with your third eye, and these circus mirror creature comforts have never seemed as urgent and splendid as they do on Merriweather Post Pavilion. This ain’t your daddy’s growin’ a lil' older n’ gettin’ a lil wiser record. Not by a hot mile.
 

“Even when a random poster says 'this could be Pet Sounds for 2009' you know there's a special sort of buzz going on.” - from a post on Kanyelive.com forum credited to Porcelain

It is no surprise that the rise of Animal Collective’s star has coincided quite neatly with the group’s mounting interest in (relatively) conventional song form, a development to which MPP is a momentary apex (of course, this peak may very well be a red herring: like each recent AC record, this one begs the question: where the hell will they go from here?) I think that the Beach Boys comparisons, inadequate as they may be in fully reckoning with the whole muse of this group, have been a way of articulating the band’s embrace of more palatable modes of song and composition, a shift that was first announced with 2004’s Sung Tongs full length.

While it is a misleading to impose a trajectory of "evolution" on a band that stubbornly resists aesthetic stasis, that re-imagines its own sound with every subsequent offering, both Sung Tongs and MPP appear as prominent turning points, records where Animal Collective’s balance of soundcraft and songcraft are radically revised.  That said, it is a testament to AC’s unwillingness to rest on anything resembling the formulaic that Sung Tongs and MPP sleep head to toe despite their shared implications.  On SungTongs the vocal tracks bleed as their own music, more textural than communicative.  By contrast, MPP is easily the group's most lyrical record, with the vocals forwarding an impressionistic, piecemeal pseudo-narrative while maintaining their instrumental weight, syllables both meaning and gleaming.  Where Sung Tongs stretched a small handful of ideas and flourishes into a larger work through the force of entranced repetition, MPP commands a diverse and seemingly inexhaustible catalogue of sounds and stacks them high, the sheer weight of their sonic language defying its own gravity, like a Babel collapsing in reverse.    

Of course, this new album’s most glaring retread from its predecessors is its instrumentation.  On MPP the guitars that were so prominent on Sung Tongs have all but evaporated; if there are any strings present, they are so heavily treated that they bear none of the earthen timber that was an essential texture in the group’s earlier music. MPP is a dense studio record with a prominent synthetic pulse, but AC does not jettison warmth by leaning ‘lectronic, instead defying the sterility associated with its own techniques. Where the likes of Kraftwerk, Ministry, and Nurse with Wound often flaunt the inhumanity of machine music, on MPP Animal Collective stake a claim in the other direction, unlocking a human potential in each knob that they tweak, casting a sonic sensibility whose romance mirrors the album’s lyrical fascination with the rapture of the small and commonplace.  This is Meadow Machine Music. Autobalm.

“(T)oday’s principle activities are alchemy and archaeology.  The idea is that, if you pick the best bits from the past, combine them, mix and match them, dust them down and restore them fondly, then the result will be something better… this is ‘perfect pop,’ pop perfected, finished off.”  - from “Indecency,” an essay by Simon Reynolds and David Stubbs, first published in Melody Maker in 1986

The premise of MPP as Animal Collective’s “pop” gesture will likely dog the record as its merits and significance are weighed in words over the coming weeks. But for AC pop – like drone, gospel, surf, avant-garde, soul, minimalism, electronica, ambient, and dance, all of which inform this record and none of which come close to defining its whole music -- is simply another way of carving a sound, not a sanding off, a mere compromise of inclinations towards strangeness and obscurity. For this group pop is not an end in and of itself but a medium, a portal on forward towards the new. It's as difficult to imagine Animal Collective congregating with the express purpose of making their “perfect pop masterpiece,” as legend tells us Brian Wilson did when dreaming up Pet Sounds, as it is easy to see them laughing in sheer bewilderment at the tense anticipation of their latest labor of love.  

Today maker myths take mere nano-seconds to germinate, and though the turnover is great for our typing chops, I often wonder what it has done for the love of listening. Where the ghosts of great albums past take on larger-than-life status in retrospect, beginning with the music and ascending backwards into a formidable history of heard magic, today the music itself often appears secondary to the aura of magnitude and universality that tends to materialize without warning, instant and microwave safe.  MPP had aura to burn long before most of us heard it, but now those of us who have heard it and do love it know that this music will not be content to stand idle on the margins of tuneless hype. Time may very well lend Merriweather Post Pavilion a legend extraordinary enough to faithfully capture its myriad treasures. By the time that happens, if it ever does and if we could even tell, Animal Collective will be somewhere else entirely, stoned and oblivious, making something new.    

Comments for Merriweather Post Pavilion review

well done.

well done.

Much obliged! tw

Much obliged!

tw

BlackMen

resulting in higher design risk, higher design and system cost, longer time to market, and compromised reliability. Gateworks has introduced several families of Network Processor Boards that address these challenges. soundcloud downloader

“Then he could be dancing

“Then he could be dancing over missing you all along,” a line that I prefer to the one provided and have come to consider as an incidental nuance to the actual lyrics. At points the singing style, the full mouthed annunciation, seems to invite this kind of alternate hearing, this accidental multi-valence). Ervin Flores

. At points the singing

. At points the singing style, the full mouthed annunciation, seems to invite this kind of alternate hearing, this accidental multi-valence http://aokmedia.co

d lending options which are

d lending options which are Shariah compliant and it has a number of tracker money as well as changeable sukuks within it’s marketplaces http://www.noahhealth.org/

If you are searching for

If you are searching for quick short-term secured loan, then car title loan is the perfect choice. For people with bad credit history this has really become a boon for getting hot cash. financialadvisertips.com

ode your NetBeans modules

ode your NetBeans modules purely in JavaFX. As an example of using NetBeans APIs in a pure JavaFX module, lisa olson

The picnic features free BBQ

The picnic features free BBQ lunch for the first 750 people, a community photo at 2 p.m., live music with Dan Sheridan, free residential electronic waste recycling, a bounce house, kite flying, soccer, basketball and more. soundcloud downloader

are Shariah compliant and it

are Shariah compliant and it has a number of tracker money as well as changeable sukuks within it’s marketplace cheap flowers

community photo at 2 p.m.,

community photo at 2 p.m., live music with Dan Sheridan, free residential electronic waste recycling, a bounce house, kite flying, soccer, basketball and more how to build a website

this is one the most

this is one the most interesting and thoughtful reviews i've ever read. brilliant

As well as within the

As well as within the unprotected type, you are able to have the mortgage quantity in between £ 1000 as well as £ 25000 with regard to the timeframe of just one in order to twenty five many years. financeaid.org

unprotected type, you are

unprotected type, you are able to have the mortgage quantity in between £ 1000 as well as £ 25000 paxil birth defects

Hong Kong has created lending

Hong Kong has created lending options which are Shariah compliant and it has a number of tracker money as well as changeable sukuks within it’s marketplaces מלוטון ללונדון

between £ 1000 as well as £

between £ 1000 as well as £ 25000 with regard to the timeframe of just one in order to twenty five many years. http://www.prymsalony.pl/

Hong Kong has created lending

Hong Kong has created lending options which are Shariah compliant and it has a number of tracker money as well as changeable sukuks within it’s marketplaces. financemarkets.org

Through a coherent policy

Through a coherent policy that has been justified on such neutral grounds, this Court finds section http://www.jmtrade.net.pl/

BlackMen

The Aspen Institute Arts Program on Monday announced that world-renowned cellist Yo-Yo Ma will serve as its 2013 Harman-Eisner Artist in Residence. soundcloud downloader

Great review.

Thanks a lot for the quality of this review!

sw308495

Tao Lei, team up with professor of electrical engineering and computer science Martin Rinard and his graduate student Fan Long to describe a system that automatically learned how to handle data stored in different file formats, based on specifications prepared for a popular programming competition. Samsung fridge repairs (london)

many reasons that you need to

many reasons that you need to be protected by insurance as a homeowner. Even if someone is trespassing on your property and gets attacked by your dog, you could be on the hook for the hospital bill Jeffrey Killino

Great one

Beautiful review. I personally couldn't agree more.

Well done man! (:

instantclassic

KANYELIVE STAND UP!

HELL YEAH!

HELL YEAH!

yay

yay klive!

good information for system

good information for system design medicine turtle Cherokee Visionssuche indianerreisen

good information for system

good information for system design Read this page

Quick Correction

Just wanted to point out that you have Avey Tare singing about a boy 'In The Flowers,' where I'm fairly sure it's a girl in the flowers - not only is it mentioned in the lyrics but the song's original title was 'Flowers in Her Hair.'

Other than that, excellent review, keep up the great work.

"(relatively) audible"

Ah, yes... Right you are! I think it was my memory of (mis)hearing some of the bootleg live versions of this song that caused the gender mix-up... I suppose the girl in the field is an avatar for Tare's wife?

I love that the flower reappears in the closing verse, with Tare on the giving end, as if to signify that he is at peace with he longing that the flower first inspired.

Thanks for the kind words!

tw

<333

I love this review!

BC

Couldn't agree more. If this album isn't a 10 I'm not sure what is...

Great!

Great review! You're an excellent writer.

The cover art kind reminds

The cover art kind reminds me of the cover art for "Fear of Music" by Talking Heads. Both it and MPP are incredible records.

beautiful and unique

could buy the 320kbs mp3s here http://peoplesmusicstore.com/walpod

simply beautiful and unique. cant get out of the flowers

mary

Hey Tits, Excellent job on

Hey Tits,

Excellent job on this review.

Your friend,
Tits

Dude, you're a freaking

Dude, you're a freaking badass. This was the best review of mpp i've read, and i've read quite a few of them. Congrats on your deep understanding and rhetoric logic, and your intense appreciation of something so weird.

Well put

this is by far the best review of this record I've come across. Pitchfork's left me sleepy and looking for a late night snack. I'm still trying to come to grips with MMP and exactly what it means - to me and in a larger context. I've never been able to articulate exactly why this band feels....important....momentous....maybe bigger than what it is they're actually doing. I just feel like their idea of music in general, and they're evolving sense of "pop" music (if they even think of it that way) might be something that transcends they way we've grown to be locked into thinking about our generation's music.

Not to get all hippy and "mind-expanding" on you. Excellent review. I've never heard of No Ripcord before (Pablo Honey?), but if there's more in here like this, count me in.

"The first song on

"The first song on Merriweather Post Pavilion is called In the Flowers and it begins with a vision in passing: Avey Tare is on his way ho watch movies online free

This review is excellent!

This review is excellent! Beyond excellent. This is my favorite sentence ever written in connection with Animal Collective. It is so accurate it hurts:

"Domesticity and romance have never sounded as ecstatic and radical as they do on Merriweather Post Pavilion."

I also love the imagery and analogy of the lemons line.

However, I do take issue with this sentence:

"The first song on Merriweather Post Pavilion is called In the Flowers and it begins with a vision in passing: Avey Tare is on his way home when he spies a boy, stoned and care free, dancing in a field."

Aside from the fact it's been pointed out that it's a girl, the person dancing is not stoned. Being stoned would be going against the line/theme of "the kid who'll dance despite anything" - because being stoned and dancing wouldn't be "despite anything," but with assistance.

Plus the opening lyrics are:
"Met a dancer
Who was high in a field
From her movement"

The high is natural.

perfectly said

Dude, you write too well, I'm slightly in awe. MPP is all that and more :)

Inspiring...

This isn't great criticism.

This IS criticism.

So inspiring to see someone writing a personal critical response to a record without taking as a given any of the projected general sentiment. That's kinda what the whole criticism thing is about. A skill which has, sadly, very little place in mainstream journalism.

Really inspiring.

...I agree on the Fleet Foxes by the way. Underwhelming.

Animal Collective Review

I love this album and this review didn't just epitomize the love I have for it but further refined it since, even on my first two listens, I sitll didn't fully understand exactly the lyrics said

Boring boringer boringest

I agree that Animal Collective sounds a lot like Fleet Foxes.
They are both probably trying to do original music.

The trouble is, its boring as two cows chewing hay.
The Beatles were original, but they were good and not boring.

Originality only goes so far. Then for heaven's sake, the music has to be listenable.
This junk isn't. it rates a big fat 0.
Don't waste your money on this snorer.

How about Monopoly

cause monopoly is way less boring than this .... album

they suck, and if you bought this album, you got suckered.

Its even worse than Fleet Foxes. and remember that Fleet is a brand of Laxative.

no no no no there are real musicians out there dying to get heard, they have real talent and are Good.

AC aint good. soryy dudes.
not even close a 0 on 10
and i do mean 0

Yes,your article is what i

Yes,your article is what i want to find and i gathered the important information which i'm looking for online.Thanks for your article.Certainly the nature of the music is factored in, with the album being touted as a time capsule from a great American past that no one has ever experienced but have somehow remembered upon hearing. You will be missed.The one place where as a venue and fan I could search by what ever perimeters I chose .Good Luck with your future endeavors.
Full House Season 1-8 DVD Box Set|Curb Your Enthusiasm Seasons 1-8 DVD Boxset|Army Wives Seasons 1-7 DVD Box Set

What a perfect article and i

What a perfect article and i learn the new information which i need.I'm looking forward your new post.At points the singing style, the full mouthed annunciation, seems to invite this kind of alternate hearing, this accidental multi-valence). This is a subject of my attention. I love studying through your site, I desired to keep a little thoughts to assist you and wish you a good extension.
Burn Notice Seasons 1-6 DVD Box Set|Grey's Anatomy Seasons 1-9 DVD Box set|Nip Tuck Seasons 1-7 DVD Box set

I followed this blog for

I followed this blog for about ten days, tried to post in it, but found myself getting angry being around the other angry people commenting and posting. On other blogs, most people are grateful we are seeing the world.The currency of hype, the elephant in the bedroom of contemporary music writing, is difficult to schematize, but I would say that it roughly equates to word-of-mouth, plus the apparatuses of journalism, plus a special x-factor.
more detail

Animal Diversity

Elephant is famous as the biggest animal in animal world and I have seen people loving this animal. Animal world is a beautiful world that consisting of so many variations in species and living style. As per the news from the researchers they are doing a great role for the balance of the ecosystem. If you want any more ideas regarding the animal world and their living style then go through 24 hr Vet chatsworth .

world and I have seen people

world and I have seen people loving this animal. Animal world is a beautiful world that consisting of so many variations in species and living style. As per the news from the researchers they are doing a great role for the wassergefuhrterkamineinsatz.de

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.