Music Reviews
The King Is Dead

The Decemberists The King Is Dead

(Beggars) Buy it from Insound Rating - 8/10

You could make a convincing case for The Decemberists being the most consistent band of the 21st Century so far. The King Is Dead is their sixth full-length LP, the latest in a run of uninterrupted quality which began with Castaways and Cutouts in 2002. Over the course of their career, they’ve seemed more than content to plough their own furrow in the margins, slowly accumulating fans and sales through word of mouth and good, old-fashioned first-rate songwriting. Upon listening to more recent Decemberists records, the most striking features are the often long, epic tracks and the meandering stories told. Colin Meloy knows how to spin a yarn, and his third-person tales of subterfuge and murder are regularly more compelling than even the most gripping crime novel. This trend reached its natural conclusion in 2009 with The Hazards of Love; a prog-rock opera of sorts, where a single tale was told over the course of the album, featuring multiple characters and repeated riffs throughout.

The Hazards of Love was so rich and complex, and had so many layers of intrigue, that it still feels as if it hasn’t fully revealed all its charms; every listen provides something new. This brings about the rather unusual position of the world maybe not yet requiring a new Decemberists record. It may be a deliberate move away from the ideas that underpinned The Hazards of Love, but The King Is Dead is as different to its predecessor as it’s possible to be while still remaining very much a Decemberists record.

Those enormous opuses? Gone: only one track on The King Is Dead clocks in at over five minutes - in fact, the whole album barely breaks the forty minute mark. Those enveloping third-person narratives? Not quite gone, but there’s a definite lyrical shift towards more impenetrable first-person tales.

Initially, these changes may appear worrying - have The Decemberists lost what made them so distinctive? It depends on how you look at it; it may not bear their most striking hallmarks, but it’s still a marvellous batch of songs. Shorn of lofty concepts, the band are able to relax into their music more, and there’s a much more pastoral undertone here. Folk singer Gillian Welch joins the quintet for lead single, Down By The Water, and is a revelation, her harmonies lifting an already fantastic song to an even higher level, much like Emmylou Harris did on Bright Eyes’ I’m Wide Awake, It’s Morning.

The Decemberists display a more prevalent Americana influence throughout The King Is Dead; strong harmonies are pushed to the fore and the overall result isn’t all that dissimilar to what Midlake achieved with The Trials of Van Occupanther. The lyrical change of direction happily hasn’t blunted Meloy’s verbal sharpness; the passage where he tenderly intones, “You were waking/The day was breaking/A panoply of song” in June Hymn is enormously affecting. This restraint is a recurring theme of the album, which truly allows the melodies to shine. And what melodies they are! The Decemberists have an innate gift for creating snippets and phrases that burrow their way into your subconscious and surface at the most unexpected times. The best example of this is the simply gorgeous January Hymn: an acoustic-led ballad with a comforting, reassuring warmth.

It’s not all campfire sing-alongs though. Rox in the Box is a rollicking tune with a dark, brooding undercurrent, while This Is Why We Fight features a rumbling rhythm and a chorus with real bite. There are minor quibbles - opener Don’t Carry It All is a little one-dimensional and All Arise! sails close to ambling AOR - but The King Is Dead remains a highly recommended collection of songs. It’s laudable that The Decemberists are still prepared to try something different, still prepared to break away from what they’re known for. There’s a tiny concern that they’ve lost something which set them apart from the pack, but as long as they’re still capable of writing such strong material, they’ll retain their deserved reputation.

Comments for The King Is Dead review

Nice review. The Ds (as

Nice review. The Ds (as they're affectionately known amongst us die-hards) are probably my favourite band and you've done a great job of describing why their fans become so obsessed, even if not everyone 'gets it'.

I would have been tempted to give this album a 7 based on one point you make - it has kind of lost what made them distinctive - but it sure is a grower.

Cheers, Joel

That's much appreciated.

As for losing what makes them distinctive, I'm not sure. If you'd asked me a few months ago what makes The Decemberists The Decemberists, I'd have said all the things that are very much front and centre in The Hazards of Love, i.e. the things I mentioned in the review (long, complex songs and third-person storytelling). However, now, while those obvious things have gone, I'd say what sets The Decemberists apart (and, in retrospect, always has done) is just the sheer quality of their songwriting. It may be less niche and they may not have as clearly a defined "sound" as I originally thought, but they're still a great band.

This is a very good album. Interestingly, all reviews I've read are positive but go down two routes - either "a change of direction after Hazards of Love but still great" or "thank God they've got back to proper albums after that ridiculous Hazards of Love idea". Clearly, I'm in the first camp; I think Hazards of Love is an amazing record and The Decemberists have spoiled us. I don't like The King Is Dead as much, but it's still a great LP by anyone's standards.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.