Music Reviews
Crack the Skye

Mastodon Crack the Skye

(Reprise) Buy it from Insound Rating - 8/10

Mastodon’s Crack the Skye has caught some flak from diehard fans regarding its pristine production and clean vocals (those metalheads are so hard to please). Well, it should be said that expensive production doesn’t necessarily equal lazy production, and clear vocals doesn’t equal selling out. Who the hell listens to Mastodon for their crooning, anyway? If Crack the Skye was a full-on instrumental piece, you could still tell me it was a concept album about Czarist Russia and I’d believe you. It’s a monarch all on its own, commanding your senses and marching you off to war with its machine-precision pyrotechnics and thunderbolt power. There’s nothing lazy or sell-outish about it.

If I had to question one thing about Mastodon after all these years, it is how in the great name of Ronnie James Dio they have managed to straddle that incredibly fine and quivering line between kick-ass-and-take-names metal and mystïc-bïrd-wïzärd Spin̈al Tapitis. They are a bit like a harder-edged Rush; those that are willing can completely turn aside the skull-and-crossbones bullshit lyrics and just enjoy the downright spellbinding musicianship at hand. Of course, even the music can fall prey to cliché (see: Dream Theater), and Crack the Skye follows Mastodon’s uncanny tradition of crafting a brand of heavy metal that is unabashed, mazelike, and above all, fresh.

Of course, that also means it is an exhausting album, despite its moderate (for prog-metal, anyway) 50 minute running time. It will drain you like a good metal album should, but it will also rack your brain. With the exception of the two epic tracks, The Czar and The Last Baron, the album is also conveniently split into small, easily-digestible portions. As for those two behemoths, they are certainly mountains worth climbing, even though they probably could have been split up.

The vocals, it should be noted, are indeed a bit problematic (when has a prog-metal band ever possessed a strong vocalist?). The band may know this, which would explain the march of guest vocalists that appear on the last couple of albums. The tandem of Troy Sanders and Brann Dailor (and Neurosis’ Scott Kelly, who appears on the title track) trade guttural growls and hoarse Ozzy Osbourne impressions that don’t get in the way but don’t really add anything to the labrynthian musical acrobatics. At least the band has the good sense to shut up for prolonged periods of time and let the music take the reins, and these are the best moments on Crack the Skye.

Aside from that fairly inconsequential annoyance, there is nothing on this album that could not please a metal fan or a prog fan. That is Mastodon’s secret. Stories of Moby Dick and now, Rasputin, give the band the same mystique that keeps Tool fans so engaged, and that leaves the band to focus on their next monolith. They are really convincing in their grandeur. The riffs, the solos, the booming drums – it all provokes a sincere sense of awe. In a musical age that is dominated by bluntness and simplicity, it’s increasingly difficult for prog rock to avoid extinction. Mastodon has; they always were, and still are, the real deal.

Comments for Crack the Skye review

it is quite the masterpiece

in my honest opinion, Crack the Skye really is a masterpiece of an album. it is marvelously and dazzingly complex, yet the musicality and melodies are not sacrificed by the band's will for technical ecstacy. I find their progressive switch (ever since Leviathan) from Harsh screamed vocals to more melodic singing to be at its apotheosis here, and i think they can actually sing well for a metal band. (i must point out your error on who handles vocal duties : Brent Hind, who sings a bit like Ozzy, and Troy Sanders, who has a deeper voice, are the lead vocalists, Brann Dailor does back vocals)

the concept and narrative of the album are probably as convoluted as the music and dense production, but that's what makes it such a great repeat listen...you find glorious new details every time you put it on. even more amazing is the band's ability to avoid the pitfalls of overly complex, technical and so called pretentious prog-rock, by remaining concise, focused and brutally powerful (something other amazing bands like the Mars Volta can't always manage to do, what with their love of over-production and noise overkill....still, you gotta love 'em)

the fact they play the entire album, "The Wall" style in concert is also a testament to their technical mastery and endurance. sure they don't move a lot while playing the songs of Crack the Skye but they execute them flawlessly and with great energy.

It's great to find someone

It's great to find someone else singing from the same 'content first' hymn sheet as me - love to know what you think about 'lorem ipsum syndrome' too,michael kors outlets which often goes hand-in-hand with design that takes place in a content-free vacuum!

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.